Python Socket Server Do Client Authentication By Using Token

There're basically two issues I'd like to resolve: Client side send query string when initializing the connection to server Server side validate user token in handshake (not after

Solution 1:

Query strings are part of HTTP URLs.

If you're building a TCP socket server instead of an HTTP server, you don't get URLs—or headers, or anything else out-of-band.* All you get is a stream of data. You need to come up with a protocol for your data that you can fit the token into.

This means the server can't "figure out who the user is and validate before establishing the socket connection". It has to establish the socket connection, read the first message, parse it, validate the token, and then drop or continue the connection. (You can, of course, put up a front-end server that accepts connections, validates them, and then migrates or proxies them to the real back-end server. But someone has to accept, read, and parse.)

Note that this is exactly what HTTP does—it can't see the query string until it accepts the connection and reads the first line of data.

Meanwhile, the example you're looking at appears to be using WebSockets. A WebSockets client can't talk to a socket server (well, unless you build a WebSockets server on top of your socket server, or a proxy in front of it) in the first place.

---

_{* This isn't quite true. You can cram 40 bytes of options into TCP header extensions. But then you have to go below the level people are usually talking about when they say "socket server"—and there's a good chance it won't make it through the internet. Also, TCP does have a concept of "out-of-band" data, but that isn't relevant here; you still have to accept the connection and read from it to get an OOB data.}